While adult stem cell research continues to show promise in various treatments, we find some scientists who are obsessed with keeping embryonic stem cell research on the public dole. The same tactics are used in their argument which are also used in the creationism vs. evolution debate. For example, some have claimed, restricting funding on ESC research is an attack on “science” despite the fact that $500 million already has been spent on ESC research.
Jack Mosher at the University of Michigan said, “It’s worrying that I could come into work one day and I might not be allowed to do my research because of someone’s ideological beliefs rather than the quality of the science.” Many specular promises are made for what might come out of the research. Last month Nature published a article critical of adult stem cells suggesting that some may have memory problems making true pluripotent stem cells and ESC more appealing.
Nature news in a court ruling against funding ESC research are lobbying congress to make a law to keep taxpayer money coming in while awaiting another decision by the court. Physorg has been the only secular outlet that has a balanced story on the advancements of adult stem cell research and ESC research. The article notes the ethical concerns with embryonic stem cell research unlike previous articles in other publications.
Dr. Paul Sanberg, admitted that “Two decades of cell-based research has been accompanied by poor management of public discussion regarding ethics.” That is because for many of them who are pro-ESC research, it’s not about ethics or the fact that adult stem cells have been showing greater promise in treatments but it’s about the money!
It has been reported that a spinal cord treatment using embryonic stem cells is going to be conducted for the first time on humans but no amount of scientific research on embryos can address the ethics of doing what they can do. The destruction of a human embryo! However, not all of this research is bad, there are other ways of obtaining ESC that can be used for treatments without ethical concerns but one thing is for sure, ESC research is not going to live up to the hype that some scientists are suggesting with their obsession using emotional ranting, hopefully this is not going to take away from adult stem research and it’s progress! The United States is for the people and by the people and the public should not bow down to scientists and always give them what they want, they are only human!